Local pickup always free · Free shipping on larger orders Find It For Me Sell Us Your Collection Our Store Visit Store Login
We buy, not just sell

Got a shed full of them?

A collection you’ve outgrown, an estate you’re clearing, or one good piece you’re ready to let go. We look at all of it, and we’ll tell you what it’s actually worth, even if that number is “keep it.”

We come to you

Anything sizeable within a couple of hours of Columbus, we’ll drive to.

An honest number

We tell you what’s valuable and what isn’t. You’re free to walk away.

All or part

Whole collection, or just the pieces we can move. Your call, not ours.

Paid on the spot

Agree a price and you get paid the same day. No consignment waiting game.

Tell us what you’ve got

You don’t need a list. A rough description and a couple of phone photos are plenty, texted to (812) 552-3535 if that’s easier. Precision and Prestige pieces, early Ertl in the box, retired DCP semis, pedal tractors, farm-show and chase units: we’re always buying, and if you’re not sure yours counts, send it anyway.

So we know whether we can drive out.

No obligation. We’ll tell you honestly what we think, and if we’re not the right buyer we’ll usually know who is.

Never miss a drop

Know before the shelf does

New arrivals, open pre-orders and Bargain Barn finds. One short email, only when there's actually something worth telling you about.

Call Shop Toys